11 years of Create8: Peter Screeton on Shopify, AI and why nobody knows what’s next

Create8 has been building eCommerce sites for 11 years. In that time the industry has gone from hand-coded stores to WooCommerce plugins, through the Magento years, into Shopify’s app ecosystem, and now into AI.

We asked our founder, Peter Screeton, what he’s learned along the way. The questions cover where the industry is heading, why branding matters more now than it did, whether Shopify’s Shop app can take on Amazon, and why moving fast beats waiting for certainty.

How did the industry get here, and how does AI compare with the shifts before it?

We’ve been through every stage of this, so it helps to look at how we got here.

When we started, you built stores from scratch. Every cart, every checkout, every database call was written by hand. It was slow, it broke easily, and it cost a fortune.

Then WooCommerce came along and made selling online accessible to everyone. A whole plugin economy grew up around it. If you needed a feature, you bought a plugin instead of spending three weeks building it.

Then Magento became the enterprise option. It was powerful, but it came with technical debt, expensive hosting and a lot of developer time.

Then Shopify changed the game. No servers to maintain, a checkout that just works, and an App Store that’s become a huge market in its own right. Every time a platform takes over, a new layer of apps, tools and services grows up around it. We’re seeing that again now, with specialist tools for B2B, for particular sectors and for particular types of brand.

But AI is the biggest change I’ve seen in this industry, and it’s not close.

Every shift before this changed where we built the store. The work itself stayed the same: a designer drew wireframes, a developer coded templates, a copywriter wrote descriptions, and someone uploaded products one at a time.

AI changes the work itself. It changes how code gets written, how data gets analysed, how a customer’s journey adapts as they shop, and how systems talk to each other. That’s a different kind of change.

So where is eCommerce heading next?

Honestly? Nobody knows. A lot of people in our industry won’t say that out loud, but it’s true.

Things are moving so fast that anyone with a fixed three-year roadmap is guessing. The ground shifts every few months. That can be daunting, but it’s also what makes the job exciting at the moment.

We’ve watched plenty of “this changes everything” moments come and go. The agencies and brands that disappeared weren’t short of talent. They got attached to one way of working and expected the world to slow down for them. It won’t. There’ll always be new tech to learn, new systems to build and new customer habits to work out.

You don’t get through that by pretending to have all the answers. You get through it by building and testing internally as fast as you can, so you’re ready to adapt when things move.

With AI producing decent copy, images and layouts in seconds, will branding become the real differentiator?

Yes, and I’d go further. Good branding, done by people, is about to become one of the most valuable things a business owns.

When anyone can type a prompt and get a slick product description, a stock-looking lifestyle shot and a clean template, everything starts to look the same. Polished, safe, and forgettable.

Once the basics are free and instant, the things AI can’t fake become rare: real taste, clear creative direction, a brand voice that sounds like someone, and a point of view. Nobody falls in love with a prompt. People connect with personality and craft.

The brands that do well over the next five years will invest in a real identity and use AI to run the business faster, not to come up with the ideas.

Will AI agents end up doing all our shopping for us?

Some of it, yes. All of it, no.

AI agents are already finding and buying products for people inside ChatGPT, Gemini and Copilot, and that will grow fast. For the boring stuff (printer paper, dishwasher tablets, a replacement charger) people will happily let an assistant handle it. That’s why we’re helping brands get their product data ready for it now. We’ve written about how in our guide to agentic commerce for Shopify brands.

But people aren’t calculators, and a lot of shopping isn’t a chore. It’s something people enjoy.

People like scrolling. They like stumbling across something they didn’t know they wanted. They like a Saturday afternoon in town, picking things up, feeling the fabric, and chatting to someone in a shop who knows the brand. An AI agent doesn’t replace any of that.

What’s changing is people’s patience. When someone has decided to buy, they want zero friction: no clunky checkout, no account forms, no faff. But they still want the fun of finding things, online and in person.

Everyone talks about “commerce everywhere”. Is the standalone website dying?

No, but its job has changed.

Shopping doesn’t happen in one place any more. Nobody sits down at a laptop and works through a five-level menu. People find and buy things in social video, in messaging apps, through AI search, and in physical pop-ups.

The website is still the source of truth. It’s your flagship shop and it holds your customer data and stock. But the places people actually buy are spreading out. Our job is to shorten the distance between someone seeing a product and owning it, whether that happens in an Instagram feed, an express checkout, an AI chat or a shop.

Could Shopify’s Shop app really take on Amazon?

Who knows until it happens? It’s a fascinating one to watch, though.

Amazon is basically a giant index. It’s built for convenience, price comparison and Prime delivery. It isn’t where you go to discover an independent brand you’ll fall in love with.

Shopify is millions of independent brands under one roof. With the Shop app, Shop Pay and order tracking, it has quietly built one of the biggest and best-converting shopper networks out there. The question is whether it can match Amazon’s convenience without every brand losing its identity.

Nobody can promise how that plays out. What I can promise is that when it shifts, our clients will hear about it from us first. We stay close to what Shopify is shipping so our brands can use new channels before their competitors have noticed them.

A lot of people expected bigger brands to move away from Shopify. What are they actually doing?

The opposite. We’re seeing more mid-market and enterprise brands move onto Shopify, because they’ve realised how much of what they need is already built in.

A few years ago the pitch was six-figure headless builds where you needed a developer ticket to change a homepage banner. Now brands want speed, stability and control.

That shows in the conversations we have. It’s rarely just a website now. It’s the whole operation: ERP and warehouse integrations, B2B portals, AI tools, acquisition and retention, and custom internal tools built on top of Shopify. Brands don’t want fragile experiments. They want something that runs the business and sells.

Is AI eating into agency margins?

At the bottom of the market, yes, and that isn’t a bad thing.

Some very small businesses now put together a basic site with AI templates instead of using an agency. To be fair, that’s a reasonable choice for them. Those projects were rarely a fit for the systems and growth work we do best.

With mid-market and enterprise brands, demand for proper strategic support is up. Internally, AI hasn’t squeezed our margins. It’s helped us protect them. We’ve built our own internal tools, taken bottlenecks out of development and sped up delivery, so the team produces more, and better, work in less time.

If your agency bills hours for repetitive work, AI is going to hurt. If you sell growth, good systems and strategy that gets delivered, it’s a massive help.

Should brands be worried about AI and security?

Yes. Any agency owner who says they’re not worried about AI security isn’t paying attention.

There’s a lot of cowboy behaviour out there. Some agencies paste client code, customer data, margin sheets and stock files into public AI tools and random apps without a second thought. That’s a huge risk for their clients.

Bigger brands are right to worry about data leaks and compliance. We take it seriously. We’re careful about which AI tools we use, client and customer data stays out of public AI models, and access to client systems is limited to the people who need it. Speed is worthless if you compromise security to get it.

After 11 years, what’s your advice for brand owners right now?

Don’t fall in love with how things were done yesterday.

Platforms will change, customers will change and the tech will keep moving. If you spend your time wishing eCommerce was as simple as it was five years ago, you’re already behind.

We haven’t lasted 11 years because we’ve got a crystal ball. We’ve lasted because the team isn’t scared of new things. We test new tools on ourselves first, put up with the learning curve, and get stuck into changes early, so our clients are setting the pace rather than catching up.

Want to talk about where your brand goes next? Get in touch with the team.

Testimonials

We’ve helped generate over £60m in revenue for the ecommerce businesses we partner with, and that’s without even talking about our B2B work. On the enterprise side, we’ve designed tailored UX experiences for brands turning over £70m annually.

Having worked with global brands over the years, we’ve had a front-row seat to the complete evolution of online retail. We’ve been building in this space since the days of completely bespoke, ground-up builds without an ecommerce platform. We navigated the transitions through the Magento and WooCommerce eras, right up to the dominance of Shopify today.

But as Peter explains, it’s easy to get distracted by the shiny new tools:

“People constantly ask where ecommerce is heading next. Yes, it’s moving toward AI personalisation, headless architecture, and B2B portals that look like premium DTC sites. But honestly? After watching every trend come and go over the last twenty years, the one fundamental truth that has stuck is this: get the product and the offer right, the information on site, and the rest will follow.

The best platform in the world won’t save a bad offer, and the slickest UX can’t fix a product nobody wants. Our job as an agency is to take an incredible product and a great offer, and remove every single piece of friction standing between the customer and the checkout.”

We operate across three connected divisions: acquisition, conversion, and retention.

When any one of these is misaligned, growth stalls. Get them right, and you build strongerconnections, generate demand, and convert more customers.

Shopify Web Design

Our Shopify Developers create bespoke themes, beautiful aesthetics with countless options, Shopify or Shopify Plus is the eCommerce platform for you.

Explore Shopify Services

Paid Marketing

Managing and executing pay per click strategies for Shopify e-commerce brands and B2B.

Explore Marketing Services

Branding

We help define your brand with clear strategy, strong positioning and creative direction, giving your business a more consistent identity across every customer touchpoint.

Explore Branding Services

Web Design

We design and build custom websites on WordPress and Shopify, fast, reliable, and built around how your business actually works. From new builds and CMS migrations to eCommerce, plugin integrations and page speed optimisation, we handle it end to end.

Explore Web Design Services

Related Posts

What our clients have to say

Purseglove

“Their willingness to take the time to ensure they thoroughly understood what we were trying to achieve. This project has been new territory for us and there were many times we simply didn't know which way to go, but we were never short of guidance...”

Richard Purseglove Purseglove
The Tiny Bed Company

“We couldn't be more pleased and proud of the final product. Our new website is a testament to their incredible skills and unwavering commitment to excellence. If you're looking for a team that is professional, skilled, and genuinely invested in bringing your vision to life,...”

Scott Mitchell The Tiny Bed Company
The Healthcare Coach

“Brilliant service from start to finish. Pete was able to create ideas that align with the brand I want to become and the ethos of the business. The whole process was streamlined and very professional. I wouldn't hesitate to recommend Pete and Create8 to anyone...”

Becky Rush The Healthcare Coach
Oohbox

“Create8 have been utterly supportive, responsive and professional. They created a stunning brand for us that we love and get great comments and feedback about. They have helped us set up our shop and are working hard to drive sales and manage the digital side...”

Julie Selby OohBox
Approved Hydraulics

“Working with the team on our new site and paid media strategy has completely transformed how our customers interact with us online. The hydraulic industry is incredibly technical, and making our products easy to find was a massive challenge. The bespoke UX they developed has...”

Dave Hicks Approved Hydraulics
Bexy Glow

“Consistent, reliable and proven results! Such an incredible, talented team. We couldn’t of asked for a better website. They brought our vision and brand to life and so much more. From the start, Create8 provided a sense of care. Very responsive on every question, every...”

Paige & Becky Bexy Glow
Craft House Coffee

“Working with the agency to bring our brand to life online was a fantastic experience. They truly understood the nuances of selling specialty coffee and worked seamlessly with our team to ensure the site felt authentically us. The bespoke subscription builder they created is incredibly...”

Daniel McGrath Craft House Coffee
Rock on Ruby

“What a breath of fresh air. After years and years and years of trying to find a web company that actually cares about what they do, whilst at the same time providing an extremely excellent service, Create8 have delivered well beyond expectation.”

Graham Dawson Rock on Ruby
Discover Images

We're offering FREE performance audits